2024 Membership

2024 Adopted Charges

The mission of the Financial Regulation Standards and Accreditation (F) Committee is both administrative and substantive, as it relates to the administration and enforcement of the NAIC Financial Regulation Standards and Accreditation Program. This includes, without limitation: 1) the consideration of standards and revisions of standards for accreditation; 2) the interpretation of standards; 3) the evaluation and interpretation of the states’ laws and regulations, as well as departments’ practices, procedures and organizations as they relate to compliance with standards; 4) the examination of members for compliance with standards; 5) the development and oversight of procedures for the examination of members for compliance with standards; 6) the selection of qualified individuals to examine members for compliance with standards; and 7) the determination of whether to accredit members.

The Financial Regulation Standards and Accreditation (F) Committee will:

1. Maintain and strengthen the NAIC Financial Regulation Standards and Accreditation Program.
2. Assist the states, as requested and as appropriate, in implementing laws, practices, and procedures and obtaining personnel required for compliance with the standards.
3. Conduct a yearly review of accredited jurisdictions.
4. Consider new model laws; new practices and procedures; and amendments to existing model laws, practices, and procedures required for accreditation. Determine the timing and appropriateness of the addition of new model laws, practices, procedures, and amendments.
5. Render advisory opinions and interpretations of model laws required for accreditation and on substantial similarity of state laws.
6. Review existing standards for effectiveness and relevancy, and make recommendations for change, if appropriate.
7. Produce, maintain, and update the NAIC Accreditation Program Manual to provide guidance to state insurance regulators regarding the official standards, policies, and procedures of the program.
8. Maintain and update the “Financial Regulation Standards and Accreditation Program” pamphlet.
9. Perform enhanced pre-accreditation review services, including, but not limited to, additional staff support, increased participation, enhanced report recommendations, and informal feedback.

RECENT CHANGES TO ACCREDITATION STANDARDS

Holding Company Models—Group Capital Calculation and Liquidity Stress Test (Effective January 1, 2026)

The F Committee adopted the 2020 changes to the Insurance Holding Company System Regulatory Act (#440) and the Insurance Holding Company System Model Regulation (#450) as significant elements of Part A accreditation standards. The revisions implement a Group Capital Calculation (GCC) for the purpose of group solvency supervision and a Liquidity Stress Test (LST) for the purpose of macroprudential surveillance. The revisions include provisions allowing the commissioner to grant exemptions to GCC for groups meeting the standards set forth in 21A and 21B of Model #450 without the requirement to file at least once. Note: The significant elements apply differently for Risk Retention Groups. Specifically, RRGs are subject to the GCC element, but not to the LST element.

Effective September 1, 2022 with enforcement for accreditation to begin January 1, 2023

XXX/AXXX Model #787 as a New Accreditation Standard

The Term and Universal Life Insurance Reserve Financing Model Regulation (#787) establishes uniform, national standards governing reserve financing arrangements pertaining to term and universal life insurance policies with secondary guarantees.
The adoption included the following elements: a) Model #787 as a new accreditation standard with significant elements as outlined in the referral; and b) the 2016 revisions to the Credit for Reinsurance Model Law (#785) are considered acceptable but not required. Although the 2016 revisions to Model #785 are not required, there are elements of #785 that are referenced in #787 that should be considered when adopting #787.  

Model 787 Accreditation Standard

MDL-787.pdf

In conjunction with this new standard, the Part A Preamble was updated to reference Model #787.

Part A Preamble

Effective September 1, 2022 with enforcement for accreditation to begin January 1, 2023

2019 Revisions to Model #785 and #786 as an Update to Reinsurance Ceded Standard

The 2019 revisions to the Credit for Reinsurance Model Law (#785) and Credit for Reinsurance Model Regulation (#786) outline the requirements for companies to take credit for reinsurance when ceded to a Reciprocal Jurisdiction.

The revisions were adopted on a “substantially similar” basis. However, it should be noted that the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act requires that a state insurance measure be “consistent” with the Covered Agreement in order to avoid federal preemption, which may be interpreted as a higher standard than “substantially similar.” Therefore, states are encouraged to adopt the 2019 revisions in close to identical form to the models. The effective date is September 1, 2022, which aligns with the end of the 60 month period when federal preemption determinations must be completed as outlined in the Covered Agreement. Enforcement for accreditation begins January 1, 2023.

Risk Retention Groups: the 2011 and 2019 revisions to Model #785 and Model #786 also apply to risk retention groups.

Credit for Reinsurance Standard-Traditional and RRGs.pdf

MO785 redlined 6-25-19_0_1.pdf

MO786 redlined 6-25-19_0_0.pdf

Effective January 1, 2021

Review Team Guidelines – RRGs

The Accreditation Review Team Guidelines include an analysis guideline specifically related to risk retention groups (RRGs). An update was made to the guideline to clarify that the guideline be applied to all RRGs regardless of accounting treatment—GAAP/SAP—or organizational structure—captive/traditional laws. Also, the term “business plan” was changed to “plan of operations” in the Self Evaluation Guide for consistency with terminology used in the federal Liability Risk Retention Act guarantees.

RRG Analysis Guideline Revision

Review Team Guidelines – Salary Ranges

The Accreditation Review Team Guidelines were revised so that states report if their salaries for certain financial solvency positions fall below the established range. The guideline is contained in Part C: Organizational and Personnel Practices of the manual, which is not taken into consideration by the review team in making a recommendation regarding the department’s overall accreditation standing.

Salary Ranges - Revisions to Part C Guidelines

Effective January 1, 2020

Part A

2014 Revisions to the Insurance Holding Company System Regulatory Act (#440)– Effective Jan. 1, 2020

The 2014 revisions provide authority to a designated state to act as a group-wide supervisor for an internationally active insurance group (IAIG). Provisions apply primarily to those states who act as the group-wide supervisor for an IAIG; however, there are also provisions that may impact any state with a domestic insurer in an IAIG. In addition, acquisitions or other changes in a state's domestic industry can occur quickly and change their role in overseeing a domestic insurer or their role within the holding company. Therefore, the standard was adopted as applicable to all states regardless of current involvement in an IAIG. In addition, the standard is applicable for RRGs in a holding company that meets the definition of an IAIG.

• 2014 revisions to Model 440
• Referral from GSIWG Regarding IAIGs

2009 Revisions to the Standard Valuation Law (#820) 
The 2009 revisions authorize a principle-based reserving (PBR) methodology for life, annuity and accident and health contracts. The significant elements for these revisions will be included in the Part A, Liabilities and Reserves standard. In addition to the life companies already encompassed in the Part A accreditation standards, the PBR elements, as adopted, are designed to apply to fraternal benefit societies. Since fraternals are currently excluded from the scope of Part A, an update to the Preamble to include them in the scope for this standard is expected prior to the effective date of the standard.

• PBR Referral - 2009 Revisions to the Standard Valuation Law 820

Part A Preamble – Fraternals Subject to PBR (Effective Jan. 1 2020)

The Part A Preamble has been revised to include fraternal benefit societies with respect to principle-based reserving (PBR). There are a limited number of fraternal benefit societies that have life business that exceeds the premium threshold to apply PBR. For those fraternals that meet or exceed the premium threshold, it is important the PBR reserving methodology is followed, and thus the laws of the regulating states must require such treatment.

• Preamble - PBR Update for Fraternals

2014 Revisions to the Annual Financial Reporting Model Regulation (#205)
The 2014 revisions relate to new requirements for an internal audit function, and it is being added as a new significant element in the CPA Audits standard. (Not applicable to RRGs.)

• 2014 Revisions to Model #205
• Memo on Model #205 Recommendations

Corporate Governance Annual Disclosure Model Act (#305) and the Corporate Governance Annual Disclosure Model Regulation (#306)

These models require an insurer (or group of insurers) to provide a confidential disclosure regarding its corporate governance practices to the lead state and/or domestic regulator annually by June 1. (Not applicable to RRGs.)

• CORP GOVERNANCE REFERAL
• MO305
• MO306

Part B1

Part B1: Financial Analysis, Timing Guidelines for Analysis of ORSA Summary Reports
Reports for groups that include multiple insurers domiciled in various states should be reviewed and shared by the lead state within 120 days of receipt. Legal entity ORSA Summary Reports (which don't cover insurers domiciled in various states) should be reviewed within 180 days of receipt.

• Review Team Guidelines ORSA Timeliness

Part B3

Troubled Company Review Team Guidelines

The changes to the troubled company guidelines in Part B3 of the Review Team Guidelines align the current accreditation guidelines with the revisions made in the NAIC Troubled Insurance Company Handbook. The updates clarify expectations about timely and effective communication between domiciliary and non-domiciliary state insurance departments. The revision is effective Jan. 1, 2020.

• Troubled Company Review Team Guidelines

Part D

Part D: Primary Licensing, Redomestications and Change of Control

The following items represent a significant change to Part D of the accreditation program and the program as a whole by allowing this section to impact a state’s accredited status:

• Update the guidelines to reflect current practices (Effective Jan. 1, 2020)
• Expand the scope to include redomestications (Effective Jan. 1, 2020)
• Subject Part D to a Recommendation A or B from the review teams with the result that the outcome can affect a state’s accredited status (Effective Jan. 1, 2022)

These changes are intended to promote stronger communication between states and reduce risks associated with licensing new companies, reviewing and approving redomestications, and reviewing and approving Form A filings.

• Part D Licensing Redomestications and Form A
• Part D Updates