Journal of Insurance Regulation

Beyond Interpleader: Protecting Insureds Through a Strategic Settlement Safe Harbor

Stern, Jonathan M.

First published: 18 November 2026 | https://doi.org/10.52227/27476.2026

Abstract

When accidents produce multiple claimants and inadequate limits, courts must decide whether to prioritize equitable distribution among victims or the promise of liability insurance: protecting the insured from ruin. In Baldwin v. Standard Fire Insurance Co. (2025), the Supreme Court of Indiana adopted Restatement of the Law of Liability Insurance § 26 and held that an insurer that interpleads its limits, names all known claimants, and continues the defense satisfies its duty of good faith as a matter of law. Missouri and Florida enacted statutes that produced a similar result in 2018 and 2023, respectively.

This article traces interpleader from its equitable origins to its modern statutory form, shows that the device was designed for disinterested stakeholders rather than liability insurers, and argues that courts, legislatures, and insurance regulators should resist efforts to convert it into a categorical safe harbor. Instead, it proposes a business‑judgment‑type rule that protects insurers who, in good faith, pursue a documented strategy to minimize their insured’s overall exposure, whether or not that strategy includes interpleader. Building on Peckham, Soriano, Voccio, and Davis, the article identifies the conduct that should qualify for protection, proposes revising Restatement § 26(2), and offers model language for state unfair claims settlement practices statutes.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.52227/27476.2026

Metrics

Coming Soon